Empowering Underserved Students to Build Positive STEM Identities

 Empowering Underserved Students to Build Positive STEM Identities

Creating positive STEM identities in students—and in educators—is a challenging task, especially when working with underserved student populations. As students enter STEM classrooms with limited content knowledge, often several grade levels behind, they carry an inner dialogue of not being enough. This self-doubt can be particularly prevalent among language learners, who often perceive themselves as significantly worse at math and science. For many, their early years in these subjects were spent focusing on decoding and language acquisition, rather than content knowledge. This gap in instruction, particularly in their heritage language, not only affects their academic knowledge but also shapes their self-perception of ability.


The Challenges of Language Learners

For language learners, the process of becoming academically proficient takes time—usually around five years to become fully proficient in an academic language. For students who began school as monolingual learners, they do not acquire the full language capabilities until 4th or 5th grade. By this time, they are already expected to catch up on years of content knowledge. As a result, teachers must scaffold content to meet the students' knowledge levels, and be intentional about their instruction and feedback. Without these targeted interventions, students face not only academic challenges but also an identity crisis in their ability to succeed in STEM fields.

The Impact of Public Speaking Fears

This lack of identity is further compounded when it comes to classroom interactions. For many of my heritage Spanish-speaking students, being called on to answer questions in class triggers a “fight or flight” response. The fear of public speaking is one of their greatest anxieties, and this often includes the simple act of being called on in class. As educators, we must be mindful of how these fears affect student engagement, particularly in an environment where random grouping and public sharing of student work are common. The question arises: how are these practices influencing students' STEM identities, especially those from underserved populations?

Creating Safe and Supportive Learning Environments

To foster positive STEM identities, we must create SAFE STEM discourse. Teachers may have to move away from traditional discussion and grouping techniques to allow for students to be able to communicate. This may mean throwing away the popsical sticks, and behavioral grouping to place students in a context they can talk in. For newcomer language learners this must be intentional, and sheltered.  As teachers, we need to intentionally plan our lessons to support students' confidence and their ability to feel safe to communicate in the classroom. This approach keeps the blood flowing to the frontal cortex, which is essential for high-level STEM thinking. The more we allow students to feel confident and safe, the better equipped they are to engage with complex concepts.

When assigning rigorous, meaningful assignments, we must consider how we provide feedback and build student efficacy. Assignments should be scaffolded in such a way that students can clearly understand expectations, supported with exemplars to guide their success. These scaffolds are essential in helping students build the necessary skills to complete the tasks at hand. By providing structure and clear examples, we give students the opportunity to experience success, allowing teacher to offer praise and limiting the need for constructive feedback on their efforts.

The Importance of Scaffolding and Structure

Without the appropriate scaffolding and structure, students are set up for failure. When students cannot meet the expectations of an assignment, the gap between them and their teachers grows. This often results in negative feedback, which diminishes students’ confidence in their ability to succeed. Furthermore, this dynamic fosters dependence on the teacher for knowledge, rather than encouraging independent learning. The goal is to foster self-reliance in students, gradually releasing responsibility for their learning and preparing them for success beyond the classroom. This is true for students in the K-12 system, but also for those in college and in their early teaching career that are teaching rigorous information and trying to apply context to the learning. I have scene as a mentor teacher the need for structure, scaffolding. Helping support young teachers by streamlining processes and providing resorces allows for more effective preporation and increased success.

The Role of Teachers in Empowering Students

As teachers, we are responsible for meeting students where they are and moving them forward. This requires creating an environment where students understand the expectations and can engage with the content. More importantly, it involves being their cheerleader, instilling confidence in them, and showing them that they can persevere in STEM fields. It is our job to push students toward rigorous content, but this must be done with honesty and encouragement, helping them believe that they are capable of doing hard things. This belief in their ability to succeed is at the heart of changing students' STEM identities.

Building Strong STEM Identities

To truly transform students' STEM identities, they must be able to see the importance of what they are learning and believe in their own potential. The question becomes: how can we as teachers support students and their families in promoting these STEM aspirations, and then provide the scaffolding necessary to help them reach their goals? It is no longer acceptable for teachers to simply hold the content and intellectual understanding, then distribute it to students. We must create environments that foster problem-solving, independent thinking, and excitement about STEM subjects, while providing the stucture, accomidations, and scaffolding needed for student success.

Empowering the Next Generation of STEM Leaders

Empowering students to see the relevance of what they are learning and building confidence in their abilities generates positive emotions, creative thinking, and student empowerment are all crucial elements for growing strong STEM identities. If we are to address the inequities in STEM participation from underserved student populations, we must equip these students with the tools and confidence to succeed. While teachers cannot remove all obstacles or make up for all academic gaps, we can walk beside our students, empowering their learning, providing positive feedback, and building the resilience they need to believe they belong in STEM fields.

Ultimately, the excitement and confidence students feel toward their learning are what shape their future in STEM. By fostering these traits, we ensure they have the tools to become not only successful learners but passionate, independent thinkers who are excited about their potential in STEM careers.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The Biggest Problem in Mathematics Education Today!

Image
  The Hidden Barrier to Math Success: Confronting Learned Helplessness in Our Classrooms As a math educator with over 20 years of experience and more than 2,500 students passing through my classroom, I’ve seen the education system from many angles. I’ve taught in affluent and underserved schools, engaged with parents, collaborated with educators, and debated with college professors about what works and what doesn’t in education. One common thread runs through all these interactions: the urgent need to address why so many students struggle with math and, more importantly, what can be done about it. Lately, I’ve had more meetings with parents frustrated that their child is struggling with math, convinced the issue lies with my teaching. But as someone who has worked to refine my curriculum, instruction, and scaffolding strategies, I have to ask: What’s really going on here? The truth is sobering. It’s not just the curriculum, standards, or even the instruction. It’s learned helplessn...
Read more

Unpacking the Debate: Heterogeneous vs. Homogeneous Math Classrooms with a Differentiated Model

Image
  Unpacking the Debate: Heterogeneous vs. Homogeneous Math Classrooms at My High School Education is a deeply personal profession, and for those of us at Warden High School, it’s more than just teaching equations—it’s about reshaping futures. Over the years, I've had many conversations with colleagues and experts who challenge our approach to ability-tracking students into specific math classes. Some advocate for the progressive move toward heterogeneous grouping , where students of all skill levels learn together in the same classroom. While this idea is rooted in equity and inclusivity, I remain a staunch defender of our current system of targeted placement. Here's why—and why I welcome the ongoing debate. The Core Argument for Ability Tracking In our district, 74% of incoming 9th graders score at the lowest level on their 8th-grade Smarter Balanced Assessment (SBA), indicating they lack foundational pre-algebra skills. These students come from a middle school that employs a...
Read more

Changing the Game: How Equity in Grading and Teaching Transformed My Classroom

Image
How Growth-Based Grading Transformed My Classroom My Journey to Growth-Based Grading Over more than two decades of teaching, I’ve come to understand that true education is about fostering each student’s growth—not by focusing on where they start, but on how far they progress relative to their starting point. As society evolves, so too must our instructional methods to meet the changing needs of students. My most profound professional transformation began when I transitioned from teaching at an affluent, majority-Anglo high school in western Washington to a high-poverty, majority-minority school in eastern Washington. This experience fundamentally reshaped my perspective on equitable teaching and grading, especially in addressing growth and achievement gaps. When I arrived at my current school, the student learning challenges I observed were immense. Many students, predominantly heritage Spanish speakers, faced multiple barriers both within and beyond the school system. Are Spanish-spea...
Read more